The products are...the Butternut quad and their single eyeshadow in Saddle! It wouldn't be such a big deal if the "studio" one [claimed better quality] was less pigmented then the $1 quad! Hmph. Not cool E.L.F.
Oh and I know your thinking that what!? They don't even look the same in the picture right!? Well...looks can be decieving! Just take a look at the dupes!
Has anyone else noticed this? /: